by David, on September 7th, 2012
The thing I found most curious in the presentations today was the idea that we think with our body. I am aware of the only half-joking idea that “men think with their penis”. I am aware of the idea of the heart vs the mind. However, I am aware that it all really exists [...]
by David, on September 7th, 2012
Human rights do not really exist. Human rights have only been thought up as a response to hardship endured under governments. I’m not sure who said it, but I remember someone saying “if freedom is not enjoyed by everyone, then it is a privilege and not a right”.
Furthering on from my discussion with [...]
by David, on August 30th, 2012
Through this exercise I have learned that ethics are not morals. It seems easy to mistake morals and ethics to be the same or at least related, but what is unmistakable is that ethical models are only models for human behavior – not models for being good people. We often say “that is unethical” [...]
by David, on August 27th, 2012
I ranked the female as the worst. She prostituted herself for $20 instead of just paying from her own pocket. She is only the worst next to the S, who profitteered off her misfortune. I don’t believe it could be said that the woman showed ultimate love by prostituting herself to get across to [...]
by David, on June 14th, 2012
My history teacher in Wales said “Without opinion the sources are boring – bland” (OWTTE).
In IB History we don’t really say “Bias” anymore, because an opinionated source is just as useful as a relatively neutral source. I say “relatively neutral” because there is no such thing as an opinion-less source. We use the [...]
by David, on June 10th, 2012
Around the last TOK – day we discussed how the scientists are looking for simple equations to solve everything. That’s what’s happening in maths. Maths is beautiful when converted into art and when it is drawing from nature. People want to make order from the chaos and they cannot appreciate the chaos. While we [...]
by David, on June 3rd, 2012
I think a language is anything which enables coherent expression and communication; languages also exist for this sole reason and achieve this sole aim. So while Maths is precise and allows ideas to be conveyed, I do not believe it is a language. A rhyme, to take the example proffered, does not constitute a [...]
by David, on May 31st, 2012
Regarding the axioms: Rene Magritee a french artist who said drew a pipe (a smoking pipe) and beneath it wrote (but in french) “This is not a pipe”. Because it was a drawing of a pipe, but not an actual pipe. You cannot smoke it.
But the points we draw are not points. They’re [...]
by David, on May 24th, 2012
I feel like everyone did well.
I myself did not expect myself to do well. I had prepared and read it back to myself (why I didn’t need any notes), but without notes I was pretty lost for words at points. I repeated stuff such as “basically…” and “so what that means is…”. This [...]
by David, on May 6th, 2012
Mathematicians should (in my opinion) be considered discoverers because maths is an expression of nature. What they discover already exists in nature (else it has no purpose). The Pythagoras Cult were largely crazy people (that thought it was bad luck to pee towards the sun) and besides Numerology, they made few other notable contributions [...]
by David, on May 3rd, 2012
I think maths may not always be too much fun, but it is really important. Maths can be used to express art, motion and nature.
I remember reading in my AS English a play called “Arcadia” by Tom Stoppard (in 1990). In this play, there is a curious 19th century,14 year old girl who [...]
by David, on April 13th, 2012
2. How can a literary work of fiction, which is by definition non-factual, convey knowledge?
A work of literature are sometimes perceived to convey knowledge. Usually this is as allegory (one story with two interpreted meanings). Tolkien said “I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations, and always have done since I grew old and [...]
by David, on April 12th, 2012
Mr Macknight said “storytelling is the most important way of knowing”, since we always claim that “this, by way of saying, is like that”. The reason for this is the “germ of a story”, then all knowledge is storytelling. I disagree. By the same quotation we can also argue that all knowledge is logic. [...]
by David, on April 7th, 2012
David Lloyd George Street, named after the British Wartime (of WWI) PM. He was also the first and only Welsh Prime Minister. Mendeleev Street, the man who compiled the periodic table. He was Russian. Lincoln Street, for his contribution to the emancipation of the slaves. Erwin Schroedinger Street for his contributions to quantum [...]
by David, on March 21st, 2012
I’m merging both a catchup and the required post into one, since I feel they are mutual.
I think that in the case of Mark Pullen, he had either been using buses all day and was unable to one near the time of death, or had been getting a lift from his father and [...]
by David, on January 21st, 2012
I think that it would not be a good idea to outright say that Umbrellaology is or is not a science. Umbrellaology contains many characteristics of science, but it seems to betray what seems sensible, and has errors in method.
The writer says that he hypothesizes based on previous findings. Scientists do this too, [...]
by David, on January 15th, 2012
There is the placebo effect, the idea that you will get better because you’ve been tricked, and there is Autosuggestion, the idea that you will get better because you say so.
Scientists have found that people will get better even if they’re told that they’re taking a placebo. In 19th century, France, developed by [...]
by David, on November 3rd, 2011
The brain in a vat question, I think is like the idea in philosophy where we are just a consciousness and that this consciousness projects everything we see, and in which only what we experience at any moment is actually in existence – anything outside your hearing or field of view does not really [...]
by David, on October 28th, 2011
We discussed a tonne of confusions due to wording in the previous TOK lesson. English is full of these terms of same wording and contrasting meaning. ie, a metal fan and a fan of metal, again a metal fan, are different, though I see no problem. I know (and now many more) people for [...]
by David, on October 24th, 2011
Graham asks in “Lies we tell kids” “There’s no difference in the meaning of “shit” and “poopoo”.so why should one be ok for kids to say and one forbidden?” I wonder usually “since the words don’t really mean anything in their used contexts, why are they swearwords”?
The answer is due to secularisation.
Many [...]
by David, on October 14th, 2011
The internet being full of knowledge, but the thing is many web users are not using it for knowlege. Since 2001, according to internetworldstats, almost a third of the world is on the internet. Facebook has over 400,000 users and counting and even hardcore tech users are usually using StumbleUpon, Reddit and various flash-site [...]
by David, on October 2nd, 2011
The article, I think, was more reliable than last week’s. It cited more experiments and books rather than continually saying certain people can’t remember who’s at fault. I do wonder regarding the interview experiment, whether the man the interviewees were supposed to meet with was affected by the knowledge of who had a warm [...]
by David, on September 21st, 2011
I thought the article was interesting, but perhaps more than just the Spanish/Japanese being unable to track cause was unreliable, like the roses by other names. It may not be language there, but bias, such as the bias we all originally had about the flavoured drinks before we decided they must have been coloured [...]
by David, on September 12th, 2011
Everything about Truman’s world is fake. Fake moon, fake wife, fake parents, engineered fears. Everyone who seems to care only wants to keep him imprisoned in a supposedly perfect land. Either Carrey is being a spastic actor as usual, or to me it seems like even his social behavior has been conditioned (accidentally or [...]
|
|
Important Dates Y12 Orals: May 22, May 31, June 5, June 7.
June 11: Y12 TOK Day
-----------------------
"The arts, ideas, natural beauty, and good conversation provide lasting pleasure."
-----------------------
"The less people know, the more stubbornly they know it."
—Werner Vogels
Your Daily Chinese Character
Comments . . . . . . are open only to students of the class, but if you are a non-student and would like to comment you can email Mr. MacKnight at ericmacknight AT mac DOT com.
Is TOK a Philosophy Course? YES, in the sense that the name of the course itself is in any dictionary effectively synonymous with "epistemology."
NO, in the sense that IB-specific ToK has many philosophical elements, but is not just philosophy. ToK is at root an interdiscipinary course that allows students to become aware of how the six subject-groups on the corners on the Diploma hexagon overlap and integrate. The interdisciplinary aspect is the crucial thing . . . .
—Bruce Bartlett
Le Collège français
Toronto, Canada
-----------------------------
"A conclusion is the place where you got tired of thinking."
—Steven Wright
-----------------------------
Webs & Chains Natura in reticulum sua genera connexit,
non in catenam: homines non possunt nisi
catenam sequi, cum non plura simul
possint sermone exponere.
Nature knits up her kinds in a network, not
in a chain; but men can follow only by
chains because their language can’t handle
several things at once.
—Albrecht von Haller (tr. Howard Nemerov)
[Epigraph to Nemerov's poem, "The Dependencies"]
About This Blog Until June 2011, this TOK blog was managed solely by Eric MacKnight. Beginning in the fall of 2011, its name changed to "DCSZ TOK Class Blog", and since then it has been used by all TOK students at Dulwich College Suzhou. The lead teacher is Julie Connah, assisted by Alan Connah and Eric MacKnight. Content posted before August 2011 was written by Eric MacKnight and his students at Suzhou Singapore International School. In August 2012 John Fitzgerald replaced Alan Connah in the DCSZ TOK team.
|
Recent Comments